• Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • 🌐 INTERNATIONAL
  • 🇧🇷 Brazil
  • 🇫🇮 Finland
  • 🇩🇪 Germany
  • 🇮🇹 Italy
  • 🇿🇦 S. Africa
  • 🇸🇪 Sweden
  • 🇹🇷 Türkiye
  • 🇺🇸 USA
agile42
  • Expertise
        • Organization
          • Organizational Change
          • How to: Agile Transformation
          • Organizational Learning
        • Leadership
          • Leadership
          • Agile Strategy Map
          • ORGANIC agility Foundations
        • Browse E-Learning
        • Agile Teams
          • agile42 Workshops, Coaching and Mentoring
          • Archetype Assessment
          • Scrum Start-up Package
          • Kanban Start-Up Package
          • Portfolio System
        • Agile Coaching
          • Coach the Coach & Train the Trainer Program
          • One-on-One Coaching
          • Team Coaching Framework
        • agile42 enables leaders to create a resilient organization and a sustainable change process.

          Marion Eickmann, CEO agile42

  • Strategic Tools
        • Organizational Scan
        • Agile Strategy Map
        • agile42 Leadership Assessment
        • After using OrgScan for 6 months we are much more aligned now.

          Tobias Schiwek, CEO Divimove

  • Workshops / Coaching
        • agile42's Workshops, Coaching & Mentoring
          • Learn more about our tailored workshops, leadership &team coaching and individual mentoring.
  • Training
        • Leadership Training
          • Certified Agile Leadership (CAL E,O,T) / ORGANIC agility®
            • Certified Advanced Education and Validated Practice (CAL II) / ORGANIC Leadership Advanced®
        • More Training
          • OKR Certification
          • Design Sprints: The Innovation Method from Google Ventures
          • Agile at Scale
          • Agile Awareness Training
          • Agile Development Practices
        • Coach Education
          • Advanced Team Coaching Course (ATCC)
          • ICAgile Team Facilitation Certification (ICP-ATF)
          • ICAgile Agile Coaching Certification (ICP-ACC)
          • ORGANIC agility Foundations Masterclass
          • Your Dashboard
          • What to expect from an agile42 training session
        • Scrum & Kanban Training
          • Certified Scrum Master (CSM)
            • Advanced Certified Scrum Master (A-CSM)
            • Certified Scrum Professional-ScrumMaster (CSP-SM)
          • Certified Scrum Product Owner (CSPO)
            • Advanced Certified Scrum Product Owner (A-CSPO)
          • Certified Scrum Developer (CSD)
          • Kanban System Design (KMP I)
          • Kanban Systems Improvement (KMP II)
  • e-Learning
        • Browse our eLearning Courses
          • Agile Foundations
          • Agile Leadership Foundations
          • ORGANIC agility Leadership Foundations
          • Scrum Foundations
          • Facilitating Scrum
          • Product Ownership Foundations
          • Kanban Foundations
          • Agile Coaching Foundations
        • More eLearning Courses
          • Facilitation Foundations
          • Facilitating Retrospectives
          • Team Dynamics Foundations
          • Self-Organization
          • Design Thinking Foundations
          • Navigating Conflicts
          • Agile Roles and Capabilities
          • Giving and Receiving Feedback
  • News / References
        • Blog
        • agile42’s Webinar Collection
        • Success Stories
        • Publications
          • ORGANIC agility Handbook
          • Hitchhiker's Guide to Agile Coaching
          • Agile Transition – What you need to know before starting
          • Do Better Scrum
        • Agile Information & Tools
        • Sharing experiences and learning from each other has always been a focus for agile42.
  • About Us
        • Our offices and contact
        • Career at agile42
        • Our Partners
        • Corporate Social Responsibility
        • agile42's Mission:

          Everyone is talented beyond their awareness and means. We help people to discover that talent and perform to that potential, achieving a higher level of satisfaction in the process. We enable them, nay encourage them to challenge the status quo, to act on their passion for learning, and to have fun while continuously improving their organization.
  • Shop
  • Menu Menu
  • Organizational Change
  • Leadership

Combatting Observer Bias in Coaching with the Team Coaching Framework (TCF)

Coaching, Team Coaching Framework
clear wine glass on brown wooden table

In research, psychology, and any other field in which someone is intended to be an impartial observer, there is a phenomenon known as the Observer Expectancy Effect, or Observer Bias. This bias happens when an observer expresses their thoughts and expectations about a situation through tone, word choice, and body language in a way that influences how the people they are observing behave.

The observer expectancy effect can be subtle, but it can also be quite profound. In some research, the observer has been shown to unconsciously change the way a subject performs in a test based on whether the observer was told they were “smart” or “dumb” subjects.

Right about now, you’re probably thinking “Well I wouldn’t do that! I’m a professional!” and there I have bad news for you. We all do it. Because it’s largely unconscious, we can’t help it. The only way that’s been found to consistently address the problem is to not have any expectations, and that is really difficult. Even if we can enter a situation with none, human nature causes us to start forming them very quickly. As coaches, our opinions and unconscious biases can mislead or misdirect those we are coaching. Therefore, it is important that we are aware and careful of this effect.

At agile42, we use a structured approach to change on teams called the Team Coaching Framework (TCF) to limit or negate the impact of any observer bias we might bring to the table.

Structured Coaching through Coaching Cards

In TCF, we leverage a structure that helps us avoid jumping ahead of ourselves in coaching. This structure starts with observations, then makes hypotheses about why those observations exist, co-created with those we are working with wherever possible. Once we settle on a hypothesis to work with, we set a goal and ways to measure that goal. Finally, we select tools to use to help get to this goal. Following this structure pushes our own opinions as far out in the process as possible in order to reduce the likelihood of influencing the process accidentally.

Micro-Observations

“The ScrumMaster is the center of conversation for the Daily Scrum.”

Does this sound like an observation to you? It isn’t. It’s actually an inference about a pattern of observations. If that sounds pedantic, that’s ok – in many cases like this, it is a fair inference about a real pattern. But when we come to our hypotheses, this nuanced difference might really matter.

When we look at the actual events that occur, we may see that every person only speaks to the ScrumMaster. Or, we might see that people primarily speak to the ScrumMaster but they also update the board and occasionally speak to each other. Both of these patterns could be expressed as the ScrumMaster being the center of the conversation, but in the first, we may hypothesize that there is a structural component leading to the behavior, while in the second it is clear that nothing is blocking the team from speaking to each other – perhaps there is social pressure or a habit leading to this behavior.

Reflecting back on these “micro-observations” can free us from anchors we’ve formed in our perspective.

Pairing or Coaching Groups

Having an extra set of eyes will almost certainly result in a different set of observations. Comparing these after-the-fact can help both coaches in removing their bias from the coaching. When doing this, the coaches can either decide to both watch everything or they can choose to have one coach focus on a very specific thing while the other takes a broad view in his or her observations. This second approach is particularly helpful when you are coaching a team through a particular challenge or new skill.

Multiple Hypotheses


One of the most common problems when formulating hypotheses is that we select the hypothesis that most closely matches our preconceptions or past experiences and then look for information that shows this hypothesis to be true.

In order to avoid this, we try to brainstorm multiple hypotheses in each coaching card. We will usually pursue only one at a time, but taking the time to come up with multiple hypotheses helps break us out of our own assumptions.

Coaching Tip: If you do this as a group, other coaches may come up with hypotheses you would never have thought of.

Invalidate Your Hypothesis


“It is tempting, if the only tool you have is a hammer, to treat everything as if it were a nail.” – Abraham Maslow

We are bombarded with a lot of information and our brain subconsciously filters out everything that we don’t think is relevant. When we try to validate a hypothesis, we can unconsciously filter out information that doesn’t support the hypothesis. This is called confirmation bias. One way to avoid this is to specifically look for information that disproves your hypothesis. Because you’re specifically looking for it, you are less likely to subconsciously filter it out.


Note: I recommend looking at the works of Robert Rosenthal, which primarily studied the effects of biases in childhood education.

May 16, 2018/by Daniel Lynn
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail

About agile42

agile42 enables leaders and their teams to create a resilient organization and a sustainable change process. We equip them with the tools they need daily to grow the business and foster the right organizational culture.

Recent Posts

  • Webinar | The Top Challenges Facing Modern Leaders 
  • Mastering Soft Skills for Effective Work: Your Path to Professional Excellence
  • How To Become A Scrum Master
  • How to Become a Product Owner
  • Navigating the Storm: Overcoming Teamwork Challenges Together

Instagram

 
 
 
Follow on Instagram

Coaching Book

The Hitchhiker’s Guide to Agile Coaching

Leadership Book

About

agile42 enables leaders and their teams to create a resilient organization and a sustainable change process. We equip them with the tools they need daily to grow the business and foster the right organizational culture.

HQ

agile42 Consulting GmbH
Grünberger Str. 54
10245 Berlin, Germany
Phone: +49 30 200 53958
Email: [email protected]

WORLDWIDE

🌐 International

🇫🇮 Finland

🇩🇪 Germany

🇮🇹 Italy

🇺🇸 North America

🇿🇦 South Africa

🇸🇪 Sweden

🇹🇷 Türkiye

🇧🇷 Brazil

Newsletter

Read more information about our privacy practices. By clicking to subscribe, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.
© agile42 2023. All rights reserved. The agile42 logo and name are trademarks of agile42 GmbH.
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Contact
  • Career at agile42
  • Legal & Privacy
  • Social Responsibility
A journey in Agility beyond ITAdvanced ScrumMaster and Scrum Product Owner training
Scroll to top